Here’s an interesting one from orgtheory via Katherine Chen’s work on organizations and charisma. I find this line of questioning very interesting. As someone mentioned in the comments the succession of Apple post-Jobs exposed, for some, the limitations of personal charisma in necessary bureaucratic processes. But I also think further back to civil rights organizations and social movements that are so closely aligned with a leader’s personality that the death or transition of the leader often leads to the demise of the organization. I think organizations of marginalized people are particularly susceptible to this. When you lack institutional power the kind of power that emanates from individual power/agency is necessarily, well, individual. It can be effective but hard to turn into processes that have the requisite stability across time and space to respond substantially to structural oppression and marginalization. Structures are necessarily stable. If your movement is not, it is difficult to sustain change. I think about the hang-wringing among HBCU presidents post “Mays-ian” model or the identity crisis of the Black Panther movement post Seale and Newton. Can organizations be made charismatic with a powerful enough narrative? It’s the kind of thing I’d like to believe.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous:

Talking For-Profits

The lovely Kali-Ahset Amen invited me to speak about some of my work on for-profit colleges on WRFG in Atlanta, GA. As is my usual schtick, I attempted to discuss the topic more broadly to include questions of race, gender, class, and access. Click to listen: tressieshow-tressietalk Many thanks to my friend, Jade Davis, for theRead More “Talking For-Profits”

Next:

Amazing Grace: The End of Student Loan Six Month “Grace” Periods

From the Chicago Tribune today comes a story about what, I agree, is a criminally under-reported change in the administration of federal student loans. The byline reads: Starting Sunday, grad students to pay interest while in school, undergrads lose 6-month grace period That’s true but a conversation on Twitter earlier today made clear that thisRead More “Amazing Grace: The End of Student Loan Six Month “Grace” Periods”